Appetizers
Slab Bacon, Brined and Smoked!! 2×2 Individual Mouth-Watering Bacon With Peter Luger Dipping Sauce Treats That Will Knock Your Socks Off!!
Our Own Take on The Classic Disco Fries!! Crispy Steak Fries, Smothered in Our Own Brisket Brown Gravy, Topped with Your Choice of American or Mozzarella Cheese
with Pulled Pork
With Chopped Brisket
Our Award Winning Brisket, Chopped and Piled High Over A Bed of Mozz Cheese Curds And Fries with Our Rendered Brisket Gravy!!
Classic Buffalo Wings, Smothered in Your Choice of Our Sweet & Smoky BBQ Sauce or Our Buffalo Sauce, Served with Celery and Bleu Cheese Dipping Sauce
What Kind of Staten Island Institution Would Be Without Them!!
Classic Long Cut Spear Pickles, Battered and Deep Fried to a Perfect Golden Brown, Served with a Twisted Play on Ranch Sauce
Salads
Add Grilled Chicken or Smoked Turkey Breast + 5.95
Our Twist on the Classic. Baby Romaine Hearts, Topped with Our Homemade Roasted Garlic Caesar Dressing, Shaved Parmesan & Cheesy Garlic Croutons
Beautiful Iceberg Wedges, Drenched with Our Homemade Blue Cheese Dressing, Topped with Our In-house Smoked Bacon Crumbles
The Juicy Lucy Burger
Our Lucy’s Are 10 Ounces (Pre-Cooked Weight) of Pat LaFrieda Meat Purveyors BlendConsisting of U.S.D.A. Prime Brisket, Short Rib, Skirt Steak and a Few Other Meats (Our Little Secret Blend)
All Juicy Lucy’s Must Be Cooked to a Minimum Doneness of Medium/Well in Order for the Cheese to Melt. But Don’t Worry . . . We Promise This Lucy Will Be Plenty Juicy!!
NOW REMEMBER!! These Lucy’s Are Like Lava Inside, So Be Careful and Take Your Time!! Most of All, Enjoy!!
All Lucy’s Are Served with Fries, Lettuce, Tomato, Pickle and Cole Slaw with Choice of Raw Onion or Caramelized Onions.
An Experience In and Of Itself! Your Choice of Cheeses: Classic Yellow American, Mozzarella, Swiss, and Cheddar. All burgers come with Lettuce, Tomato, & Waffle Fries!
16oz Classic Juicy Lucy with 3 Hefty Slices of American Cheese on top and a Slice of our award winning Brisket on top of that served with French Fries
If you can eat 3, then they are FREE
Traditional Hamburgers
Yes, We Have Traditional Burgers As Well!! Our Burger Blend is the Same As Our Juicy Lucy Burgers, Just without the Cheese Inside
add Cheese . . . + 2.00 / add Smokehouse Bacon . . . + 3.00
with Lettuce, Tomato, & Waffle Fries
with Lettuce, Tomato, & Waffle Fries
with Lettuce, Tomato, & Waffle Fries
The “Beyond” Burger – And It’s Made from Pea Protein!! Looks, Tastes and Acts Like a Burger!!
Burgers Can Be Prepared To Your Choice of Doneness, but Remember . . . U.S.D.A. Recommends All Burgers To Be Cooked To a Minimum Doneness of 160°
BBQ
*All Barbecue served at Juicy Lucy BBQ is Smoked on Our Custom Built Pits For Up to 14 Hours!! When You Dig Into Your BBQ You Will See a Pink Ring Around the Perimeter of Your Food, this Chemical Reaction – Known as the “Smoke Ring” – Is Our Pride and Joy and Can Only Be Achieved Through This Slow Smoking Process!! Get Ready For This Experience!!
Price by the half pound
Meats
By The Half Pound
1/2 Chicken
Family Cook Out
Serves 4 people
Served with your choice of 4 Sides
BBQ Specials
Large Bowl of NYC`s Mac Truck Award Winning Mac Cheese Loaded Brisket, Pulled Pork and One Spare Rib
Sides
Brisket is Added to Our Baked Beans
Smooth & Creamy
( 2 Slices)
Sandwiches
*All Sandwiches Are Hand Carved with Our Smoked Meats and Made To Order!!
All Sandwiches Come with Fries, Pickles and Cole Slaw on the Side
Slices of our housemade Pastrami Brisket, Piled on fresh Rye Bread with Spicy Mustard
Our Texas Version of The Philly Cheese Classic!! Moist Brisket, Piled High with Melted Cheese, and grilled onions and peppers served on a toasted hero.
Our Award Winning Brisket chopped and served with our Espresso BBQ sauce and Served on freshly baked brioche bun.
Pulled Pork, Piled High with Cole Slaw and Our Sweet & Smoky Sauce, Served on Freshly Baked Brioche Bun
Dessert
Deep fried Churros with 2 Scoops of Vanilla ice cream and Topped with Caramel Sauce
Filled with Cream Cheese